Видео

Why so underrated yt channel 😕

I actually liked Yates’ films. Yes, the acting seems more plain and less expressionistic, but for me it enhances the mood and it emphasizes that Harry and his friends aren’t kids anymore. It all gets more serious and the more subtle acting reflects this well I think. The editing might be better in the other films, but again, I like his minimalistic take in many scenes. As a director, he doesn’t force you to feel anything with camera movement, but choses a more plain approach that evokes a serious ann ominous yet subtle mood.

Goblet of fire is shit bruh. It’s not great at all.

Thanks for finally pointing this out. He did horrible job. Dumbledore asked CALMLYYYY

no hate but i dont know why he made dumbledore an extrovert like he is a mysterious calm proffesor

When I read the title, I was disagreeing and already collecting arguments in my mind, but after watching this video I can completely agree. For me Columbus and Cuaron were the best directors. There is a weird feeling about the last 4 movies and I could never explain why. They were the movies I found myself coming back to the least, especially compared to the third movie. But you nailed it and perfectly explained why I feel like that about the movies. Thank you, for making me realize. It was a great video.

The only band that wasn't bought by Satan......an that is why they tried to critize their music. The music is organic and not AI

Chris Columbus is my favorite. His films have a certain charm to them. I wish he directed every film except for maybe the darker ones

Фріда неперевершена! I let the music speak супер!

cant understand half what the narrative says

I wouldn't say what you did here was justify. I'd say what you did was more explain WHY he was, while calling out his misdeeds.

Thank you for this analysis, now I can understand the differences between Yates’s versions and the others and understand why I absolutely hate Yates’s versions. The movies he directed are so dull and boring, that’s not what Harry Potter is supposed to be like. I haven’t watched his movies since forever. It is clear he wasn’t chosen for all four movies because of his directing capabilities, probably some insider preference going on.. PoA however is my favourite, it always fresh and new and fun and engaging and nostalgic. Cuaron did an absolutely amazing job, he was the best, even though Columbus did amazing as well in creating the visuals that would become the outline / reference for upcoming movies, especially Hogwarts itself and conveying magic and innocence for a younger audience.

Oh my God, finally someone who agrees with me!!! I HATED how he directed the films, especially the half blood prince with its golden filter that made the Hogwarts Express look like it was traveling trhough the freaking desert!

my biggest gripe with yates realisations, is how his version of magic feels like LED lights while in the first four felt like fire light

Nah, after the travesty that is Goblet of Fire, he fixed it

I knew something was wrong when a main character DIES and it passes so quickly without emotion...

I was / am a huge fan of the first two and none have came close imo they have so much style and magic 🪄. Whimsical heartfelt throughout the first two Chris Columbus is one of my favorites. He has such a great understanding of the atmosphere it’s set in .I thought the some of the playful tones worked cuz it is a kids story but could still be dark when the story asked for it like in chamber of secrets .

I'm a bit late but I just wanted to say this video analysis is amazing! Thank you

I feel David Yates was the result of Rowling’s insistence on controlling everything. He is the sort of director who is competent but just does what he’s told. The earlier directors all ADDED to the source material. Edit - It’s depressing you had to pin a comment asking for no racist comments… 😔 Excellent video essay 👍

If we’re talking about technical & cinematographic choices, Mike Newell committed the biggest crime in terms of character direction. I understand he was aiming for a more comedic film, but the dialogue, actors’ movements, everything felt so out of place and jarring. Especially when juxtaposed against Cuaron’s final product (*Chef’s kiss*)

Excellent

I wouldn't say yates did a bad job. Every director has their own style of film making but when i watched 5th ,6th and rest of the movies it didn't feel i was watching a harry potter movie , felt just like any other regular fantasy movies nothing special.

Yates movies are so freaking boring, my god. How can anyone think that GOF was worse than any of the Yates movies?

Where can I find this movie with subtitles? Please reply.

This is exactly why Fantastic Beasts isn't working. Yates just makes boring movies. The magic is gone. I remember Half Blood Prince was the first time I felt bored watching HP movie. I couldn't get through the newer Dumbledore movie. I shut it off and gave up.

Love your videos, keep it up

DO NOT REDEEM!

It took people the entire decade they were around to figure that ABBA "could be dark musically" and even when they made it so blatant (a full album of it in '81) and 1982 should that ever be completed-which it technically is if you add the CHESS singles to it, plus all of the Gemini album in 1985 that is pretty much an ABBA album, people only reacted with askance at the best! Idiots. But there were dark songs before, even 'Dancing Queen' has a questionably dodgy underlying subtext, but no, they miss that of course because of the wonderful pop spirit of the song and the beautiful vocals, harmonies and catchy as hell music! D'oh!

You called the fourth movie great? It was the worst adaptation, closely followed by sixth

i genuinely appreciate you man.

What I loved about the first 4 films is they each had their own distinct style and tone.

I would give my entire lifesavings if Alfonso Cuaron direct all of the movies

Alfonso Cuarón ruined the Harry Potter series, because the third book is the most important for character development!

Yates is fine Newell is so much worse

For me, Newell's work was at least as disappointing as Yates's. He entirely misunderstood/disrespected the atmosphere and spirit of The Goblet of Fire, which Cuarón managed to pick up so brilliantly with Azkaban. Although the famous exaggerated Dumbledore scenes embodied this failure on their own, other characters - Brendan Gleeson's hurt me the most - were mismanaged the same cartoonish way in my opinion. I tried to rewatch it many times as I got older, but the way that movie communicates is simply annoying for me, though I loved the book.

Proud to be bengali❤ ঋত্তিক ঘটক 🙏

Couldnt disagree more, the Yates movies mature the series and enhances the dark and grimnes of the movies

I would say that Yates best one was Order of the Phoneix, but after that he doubled down on his bland directing style I'm the next three films that don't do justice to the Half-blood Prince and Deathly Hollows books. And his work on the Fantastic Beasts movies turn out to be very disappointing.

Ray-Ghatak-Sen what a trio we have...😢😢😢

Yes David Yates was not a good director but how on earth can you say that Goblet of Fire was GREAT? It is categorically the worst film in the ENTIRE series. From their appearances, to the script, to exclusion of important characters like Bertha Jorkins and Bagman and the AWFUL portrayal of Dumbledore. Yates was sooooo much better than Mike Newell who even confessed in an interview that he couldn't even manage to read the entire book. How is that director labelled as someone good???

Lore of The Man Who Ruined Harry Potter | Video Essay momentum 100

is this movie available in english subtitle?? if yes , in which plateform??? i searched a lot but could not find,,,please help me

I will never get over how well Columbus captured the innocence and whimsical aspects of their early years while Cuaron pushed the film towards the darker and more intense stages of the story. Both directors complement each other really well.

Hi there. Where can I watch it with the subtitles?

Good stuff

Newell is the worst he was about to burn the WHOLE FORBIDDEN FOREST AND HE ALWAYS WHINED ABT HOW BIG THE BOOK IS sry cap lock

Great video!

Thanks brother love from Chennai ❤

I recognize an Asian home when I see one.

oh my gosh i didnt realize how important cinematography was until this video